Clean Energy SF: San Francisco, fog then sun, est. 2026

Vol. 1 - No. 14 - Thursday, September 24, 2026 - Free to readers

Bioenergy ยท Analysis

What Muni's diesel buses actually burn

SFMTA's remaining diesel coaches run on R99 renewable diesel, a drop-in fuel made from fats and oils. Here is what that quiet swap cuts, what it doesn't, and where the fuel comes from.

I. What R99 actually is

Renewable diesel is not biodiesel, though the two get mixed up constantly. Biodiesel is made by a chemical reaction (esterification) that leaves a fuel slightly different from petroleum diesel, which is why older blends were usually capped at roughly 5 to 20 percent of the tank. Renewable diesel is hydrotreated, meaning fats and vegetable oils are reacted with hydrogen until the molecules are nearly identical to the ones in fossil diesel.

Because the finished fuel is chemically close to the real thing, it is a true drop-in. An engine cannot tell the difference, a cold and foggy San Francisco morning does not gel it the way old biodiesel blends could, and the maintenance shop does not need new parts. That is the whole appeal: a fleet can cut the carbon in its tank without waiting years for new buses or new chargers.

II. What it cuts, and what it doesn't

On a lifecycle basis, counting the farming, refining, and shipping as well as the tailpipe, California's fuel regulators credit renewable diesel with large reductions in greenhouse gas emissions compared with fossil diesel, often on the order of half or more depending on the feedstock. Those figures come from the state's accounting under the Low Carbon Fuel Standard (the California program that scores fuels by their lifecycle carbon), and they shift year to year as feedstocks change.

What renewable diesel does not do is make the bus clean at the curb. It still burns, it still puts out some nitrogen oxides and fine particles, and the cuts in local pollution are real but modest next to the carbon story. For a kid with asthma on a busy corridor like Mission or Geary, a renewable-diesel coach is better than the old fuel and still not an electric bus. This desk thinks that distinction matters more than the headline percentage.

III. Where the fuel comes from

The feedstock question is the honest soft spot. Renewable diesel is refined from fats, used cooking oil, and vegetable oils, and very little of that is produced in California, let alone near the bay. Much of the state's supply is refined elsewhere and shipped in, and the feedstock itself (soybean oil, animal tallow, imported used oil) travels a long way before it reaches a Muni tank.

Fair questions follow about how much new land or crop demand the fuel drives, which is exactly what the lifecycle scoring is meant to capture and exactly where studies disagree. If you want to check the claim rather than take it on faith, the state publishes the fuel volumes and carbon scores, and SFMTA publishes what its fleet runs on. The gap between a clean-sounding label and a verifiable number is where a skeptical reader should live.

IV. Worth watching this month

1. CARB's quarterly Low Carbon Fuel Standard data updates are the place to confirm whether renewable diesel volumes statewide are still rising or starting to level off, a routine release worth a glance.

2. SFMTA's next climate or fleet update is the document to watch for how many battery-electric buses have actually entered service, since that is the number that eventually shrinks the diesel fleet this fuel supports.

3. Any SFMTA budget or procurement item on bus purchases is worth reading for whether electric or diesel coaches are being ordered, which signals the real pace of the transition rather than the stated one.

4. Watch for state-level debate over LCFS credit prices, since a sharp drop could change the economics that make renewable diesel affordable for public fleets, though this is a slow-moving fight.

Frequently asked questions

Is renewable diesel the same as biodiesel?

No. Biodiesel is a different molecule and is usually blended in small amounts, while renewable diesel is hydrotreated to be nearly identical to fossil diesel. That is why it works as a full drop-in with no engine changes.

Does this mean Muni's diesel buses are clean now?

Cleaner, not clean. The lifecycle carbon is cut substantially, but the bus still burns fuel and still emits some pollution at the curb. It is a step below an electric bus, not the same thing.

Why not just buy electric buses instead?

SFMTA is adding them, but a full fleet turnover takes many years and a lot of charging infrastructure. Renewable diesel cuts carbon on the coaches already on the street in the meantime.

Where does the fuel come from?

It is refined from fats and vegetable oils, mostly outside California, and shipped in. Very little is produced locally, which is part of why the feedstock question stays debated.

References