Grid ยท Analysis
How San Francisco closed its last in-city power plants
Two fossil plants in the city's southeast ran for decades, then shut in 2006 and 2011. Keeping the lights on without them meant new wires, not just goodwill.
I. Why San Francisco was a hard place to keep lit
San Francisco sits at the tip of a peninsula, which engineers treat as a load pocket (an area reachable by only a limited set of transmission lines, so local generation counts for more than it would inland). For years, the Hunters Point and Potrero plants were the insurance policy against that geography. They were neither efficient nor clean, but they sat inside the pocket, and that is what the grid valued.
That insurance had a formal name, reliability-must-run, or RMR (a contract in which the grid operator, the California Independent System Operator, pays a plant to stay available because the local network depends on it). Retiring the plants meant letting those contracts lapse, and letting them lapse meant proving that other wires could carry the load instead. No proof, no permission to close.
II. The wires that let the plants go dark
Two projects did most of the heavy lifting. The Jefferson-Martin line, a 230-kilovolt transmission line (a high-voltage link between substations) approved by the California Public Utilities Commission and energized around 2006, strengthened the path carrying power up the Peninsula into the city's southern edge. It gave the grid room that the old plants had been filling.
The other was the Trans Bay Cable, an undersea high-voltage direct-current line buried in the bay floor that runs from Pittsburg across to the Potrero shoreline. It carries roughly 400 megawatts at full output, per the project's public materials, and it came online around 2010. With a second major import path in place, the California ISO could finally sign off on releasing Potrero from its must-run obligation.
III. The neighborhoods that pushed, and what is left
None of this was handed down from above. Residents of Bayview-Hunters Point and the Potrero Hill and Dogpatch flats organized for years, tying the plants to asthma complaints and to the plain unfairness of parking the city's pollution in its lowest-income, most heavily Black and Latino corner. The closures are, as much as anything, the result of that pressure.
What is left is messier than a clean ending. The Hunters Point site sits within a larger shipyard cleanup that has run for decades and is not finished, and the Potrero waterfront is slated for housing and mixed use that has moved slowly. The air is better without the stacks, though trucks, the freeways, and the port still shape what people breathe. Honest version: the plants are gone, the burden is not entirely.
IV. Worth watching this month
1. The California ISO's annual local capacity requirements study is the document to watch for whether the greater Bay Area still shows a tight reliability margin, and it is more routine than alarming in most years.
2. CPUC transmission and reliability proceedings occasionally revisit the San Francisco area, so a reader can watch the commission's docket pages for any new filing touching Peninsula import capacity.
3. CleanPowerSF rate and supply updates from the SFPUC are worth a glance each cycle, since they shape what city customers actually pay and where the power comes from.
4. Redevelopment hearings for the Potrero power plant site and the Hunters Point Shipyard come up at city planning bodies, and those are the venues where the land's next use is decided.
5. Bay Area air-quality monitoring near the old plant sites is routine, but worth checking if you want a number on local air rather than a memory of the smell.
Frequently asked questions
Are the plants truly gone, or just sitting idle?
Both stopped burning fuel years ago, Hunters Point in 2006 and Potrero in 2011. The structures have largely come down, and both sites are now tied up in cleanup and redevelopment rather than power generation.
Does San Francisco generate any of its own electricity now?
A little. The SFPUC's Hetch Hetchy hydropower system supplies many city facilities, and rooftop and community solar add a modest share, but most of the electricity used in the city is imported over transmission lines.
What is a load pocket, and why did it matter here?
A load pocket is an area served by only a few transmission paths, so losing a line or a local plant hits harder than it would elsewhere. San Francisco's peninsula geography made its in-city plants hard to retire until new wires were in place.
Did closing the plants raise my bill?
It is hard to isolate. Transmission projects are paid for by ratepayers across a wide area, and no single line on a PG&E or CleanPowerSF statement traces back to these closures, so anyone quoting a precise figure is guessing.
References
- California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), State regulator (.gov); search its proceedings for the Jefferson-Martin transmission approval and San Francisco reliability record., www.cpuc.ca.gov.
- California Independent System Operator (CAISO), The region's grid operator; publishes local capacity studies and the reliability-must-run designations behind the closures., www.caiso.com.
- California Energy Commission (CEC), State agency (.gov) that licensed power plants; its records cover the Potrero plant's permitting and retirement., www.energy.ca.gov.
- Pacific Gas and Electric (PG&E), The utility that ran Hunters Point; company pages describe the station's history and shutdown., www.pge.com.
- Trans Bay Cable, Project page for the undersea line into San Francisco, with its route and roughly 400-megawatt rating., www.transbaycable.com.
- San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC), Runs CleanPowerSF and Hetch Hetchy Power; explains where city customers' electricity comes from today., www.sfpuc.org.